HIMYM last season wasn't great, and the finale wasn't what it should have been. I'm not sure it should be in the worst ever though it's not GoT bad
this post was submitted on 17 Aug 2025
28 points (96.7% liked)
Television
1453 readers
554 users here now
Welcome to Television
This community is for discussion of anything related to television or streaming.
Other Communities
- !casualconversation@piefed.social
- !movies@piefed.social
- !animation@piefed.social
- !trailers@lemmy.blahaj.zone
Television Communities
A community for discussion of anything related to Television via broadcast or streaming.
Rules:
- Be respectful and courteous to all members.
- Avoid offensive or discriminatory remarks.
- Avoid spamming or promoting unrelated products/services.
- Avoid personal attacks or engaging in heated arguments.
- Do not engage in any form of illegal activity or promote illegal content.
- Please mask any and all spoilers with spoiler tags.
founded 3 months ago
MODERATORS
I was satisfied with the LOST ending. At least enough for it not to be #2 behind GoT. I know it was polarizing but its not even in the same league as the mess of GoT.
The problem with the LOST ending was, it wasn't planned. They wrote themselves into a corner.
I'm good with the ending, too. I'm also good with people roasting them for it. And I'm also good with situations like in FROM where Harold Perrineau said he wouldn't work with them (same people) if they didn't have the ending pre-planned in advance. They even poke fun at the LOST ending in one of the early episodes, implying it won't go that way.
All fair. But the LOST ending didn't ruin the entire series, like GoT's did. Like, the ending of GoT retroactively made the rest of the show unwatchable, whereas ive watched all of LOST a couple times, and it's still great.
I never understood the hate for the Lost ending either. Made sense to me.
off the top of my head at least Battlestar Galactica should be on the list instead.
I completely agree on both points. BSG is one of my favorite shows but yeeeesh that ending is not a point of pride.
I watched Lost well after it came out (during the pandemic) and I thought the ending was fine. It wasn't a great ending, but it didn't ruin the show. It doesn't make the rest of the show terrible, just makes the ending weird but ok.
Similarly the ending of How I Met Your Mother, if you just ignore the last episode then the show is still great. Sure the ending is bad, but the show isn't ruined.
Now that's not true for Game of Thrones. That show builds to the ending and when that ending goes nowhere, or character motivations are completely wrong, that is a failure.
Now Dexter is weird. While the last season was kind of a mess, had Dexter just gone off into the sea and died, I guess that would have made sense. But really the whole season was rough, so anything they did wouldn't have worked. BUT! They left the door open. Recently they followed up. The newest Dexter has been pretty entertaining.
I actually think it is in the same league. It was a total cop out ending.
what was the cop out? the entire "flash forward" world was built to set up that ending.
For me it was The Man in High Castle. That ending made zero sense. To me it was weak and left a ton of things unanswered.
Star Trek: Enterprise was not in the list. 0/10 article.
Supernatural !!! The penultimate episode should have been the last one. The last episode was total trash. I am still mad about it.
To be fair, it probably should have ended many times, and kept going, heh.
Me too, but to be fair Covid fucked up the episode they wanted. They claim the final episode was going have guest stars from everyone who ever was on the show.
I hated the ending but worse is I stuck with that show for 15 years even after it should have ended in season 8. Closes the gates of hell would have been a great ending. Or even season 11 would of also made a good one with Sam using Death weapon to slay Dean. The show just went on to long. But I watched every episode when they aired. I stay loyal all the way. Even after it went off the rails.
Was it to much to ask that writers for the show at least be fans of the show and watch past episodes. They fuck up a lot past episodes by ignoring things that had happen or dialog that took place in earlier episodes.
Dispatches From Elsewhere.
This was so good for 9 whole, long ass episodes, and then the last episode just shat all over every single thing that had happened previously and resolved nothing, because it had to be meta and a dumb allegory for writing a script while overcoming alcoholism and it didn't even make sense so it just meta-ed itself again to get out of having to tie up a single god damn story line.
Seriously though, the first episode is fantastic and beautiful and I do recommend watching it, but just don't go past that because you will get invested in the story and have all your hopes crushed as not one iota of it pays off.
Dexter technically hasn't ended, unless you mean the series Dexter.
There have been two spinoffs, and the second one hasn't ended yet. So for the people who say Dexter should have died/been exposed/caught/shamed at the end... well... it hasn't ended yet.
Also, the books are wilder. In the last one I read, the little boy and girl of Rita's were getting into killing. The little girl says "I don't kill because I'm a girl, so I'm just the lookout for my brother." The brother kills animals, the girl watches out, distracts anyone who might come around, basically runs interference for him. IIRC they're twins and maybe the book tried the whole "psychic twin connection" stuff? It's been a while. The book just gave creepier vibes than the previous ones and I quit there.
Tap for spoiler
Also let's not forget Cyber Doakes! That was wild.