This is not an e-scooters vs cars issue. Just a safety advice. Anything that goes fast is a bit dangerous.
Fuck Cars
Your hub for collection of materials that contribute to a world with less car ownership. Including buses, motorcycles, bicycles, skateboards, longboards, scooters, hoverboards, e-scooters, pedestrians, walking, running.
Learn
- AboutHere - Videos to understand your city better. Creator is based out of Vancouver, BC.
- NotJustBikes - Stories of successful and not so successful urban planning.
- RMTransit - In-depth analysis of public transit systems around the world.
- Cycling Fallacies
Basic Rules:
- be constructive: there is no need of another internet space full of competition, negativity, rage etc.;
- no bigotry, including racism, sexism, ableism, transphobia, homophobia or xenophobia;
- be empathic: empathy is more rebellious than a middle finger;
- no porn and no gore: let’s keep this place easy to manage;
- no ads / spamming / flooding, we don’t want to buy/consume your commodified ideas;
- occasional self-promotion by active members is fine.
Chat
Get Involved
- Alberta - Alberta Cycling Coalition
- Edmonton - Bike Edmonton
- British Columbia - The BC Cycling Coalition
- Vancouver - HUB Cycling
- Victoria - Capital Bike
- Manitoba
- Winnipeg - Bike Winnipeg
- Ontario - Share the Road Cycling Coalition
- Ottawa - Bike Ottawa
- Toronto - CycleToronto
- Quebec - Vélo Québec
- Saskatchewan
- Saskatoon - Saskatoon Cycles
* message the mods to add any missing local advocacy groups.
Well yeah, scooters cause lots of injuries. so do bikes, skateboards, whatever. That's life. As an EMT I saw a teenager superman off an escooter(I guess the front wheel hit a rock or something)... broke a wrist, a jaw, and a collarbone. Surely a concussion as well.
But that doesn't mean they aren't useful or responsible gifts, you just need a helmet and to actually learn how to ride the thing.
And you dont give cars to children, so the comparison there is not relevant.
That said, painting scooters as an irresponsible gift is a bad look.
you just need a helmet and to actually learn how to ride the thing.
You learn how to ride the thing on a battery-less version, which is what the poster recommends.
I would also say "you need to learn how to ride the thing... responsibly." Anyone can learn the basics. It takes time to build a habit of safe riding, both for the rider as well as for other riders and pedestrians.
And you dont give cars to children, so the comparison there is not relevant.
Right, the more apt comparison is that you don't use a Dodge Viper to teach people to drive.
Pedantic. Learning how to ride an escooter can be achieved in many ways. You detail one. I agree that is a sound way to learn.
Responsible riding is riding, in the context I was obviously discussing.
Op discussed a car hitting pedestrians as a comparison to the danger of scooters, which is what I was calling irrelevant re giving to children.
I had a coworker that fell off his e-scooter twice in two weeks. Ended up with a broken arm. Turns out roads in the US are shit, which is why we recommended a bike to begin with.
He was saved from serious injury because he was wearing a helmet. It’s not even controversial to say that if you don’t wear a helmet while riding a bike, scooter, skateboard, or any other wheeled vehicle that doesn’t fully encase you, you run a real risk of hitting your head and actually dying.
It is super weird how defensive some people get about the helmet thing.
No kidding. I'm a decent cyclist. I've bounced more than one helmet off the ground with my head in it. This is why I always wear one, and always insist my kids do too.
Cool cool. If the batteries are the problem I'll just use a gasoline one. That's safer, right?
That's the message I'm getting.
To be extra safe, operate it only within view of papa Doug Ford. Whether at his cottage, or indoors at queens park.
Kids frankly can get around just fine on a bike without a motor, this isn't saying that active transportation is bad.
I can't speak for everywhere, but back in college, people would zoom across on their scooters with no regard for safety. Down the hills, through pedestrian crowds, on the road, etc. They also never wear safety gear too.
I know a friend who fell really badly because they needed to brake hard since the car in an intersection pulled up too far. Luckily she just needed a lot of bandages and ointment for about a month.
I'm not saying e scooters are a bad thing, but roads in the US are not built for them (esp since bike lanes are not well maintained) and people do not wear gear for the fall