6
WIRED Called Our AirGradient Monitor 'Not Recommended' Over a Broken Display
(www.airgradient.com)
this post was submitted on 06 Aug 2025
6 points (100.0% liked)
Technology
353 readers
177 users here now
Share interesting Technology news and links.
Rules:
- No paywalled sites at all.
- News articles has to be recent, not older than 2 weeks (14 days).
- No videos.
- Post only direct links.
To encourage more original sources and keep this space commercial free as much as I could, the following websites are Blacklisted:
- Al Jazeera;
- NBC;
- CNBC;
- Substack;
- Tom's Hardware;
- ZDNet;
- TechSpot;
- Ars Technica;
- Vox Media outlets, with exception for Axios;
- Engadget;
- TechCrunch;
- Gizmodo;
- Futurism;
- PCWorld;
- ComputerWorld;
- Mashable;
- Hackaday;
- WCCFTECH;
- Neowin.
More sites will be added to the blacklist as needed.
Encouraged:
- Archive links in the body of the post.
- Linking to the direct source, instead of linking to an article talking about the source.
founded 3 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Yeah, that's a pretty shit way to do a review.
"I cannot recommend the iPhone, because the USB cable that came with our unit was defective and we could not power it on. Rating: F"
Reviewing a broken unit doesn't tell the reader anything about the product. It's lazy and harms both the manufacturer and the reader who's expecting fair reviews.
Lazy work by that writer and the editor who approved it.
It does expose quality assurance problems. Products shouldn't be defective out of the box. It happens: you send it back and get it replaced. But the reputation is damaged already.
Sure, it's a thing to note. I see these things mentioned in reviews regularly, but it's just "we had a problem with x, but it was covered by the warranty and they sent a replacement."
Reviewing the product as if the broken screen is part of the product is lazy and unprofessional. Not to mention, kind of besides the point for most users who are likely plugging it into a smarthome system so the information is readily accessible from their phone or smartwatch.
Ironically, because of this post I looked at some other reviews (who's screen had zero issues) and they were all positive. Especially about the integrations with other open source projects in the home automation space.
I've looked at adding air quality monitoring to my system, there's a lot of modules available, but unless you want to build them into a Raspberry pi and write your own integrations your choices are pretty limited (and often tied to proprietary, cloud-based, products).
$200 to have all those sensors professionally assembled, with a case and software support for the FOSS ecosystem is pretty good. Even if it didn't have a screen at all.