news

(went too long, here’s the rest of the comment)

What should China have done instead?

To understand how to get out of this mess, we need to understand what made the post-war Marshall Plan so successful in the first place.

As WWII was coming to an end, and with the war economy under FDR solving the unemployment issue caused by the Great Depression, and instead greatly increased the wages and living standards of the working class in America, the country now faces a new world that is rapidly demilitarizing. To keep American industries running and to prevent a massive layoffs that would have plunged the US into a recession once more, the Marshall Plan was enacted.

Now, did the US lowers the wages of its own people to maintain its export competitiveness? No, the US literally gave Germany a whole lot of dollars, which enabled the Germans to purchase American goods made by American factories and workers, and in turn raised the income of the American working class. This was what led to the postwar boom of the US economy in the 1950s. Eventually, the reindustrialization of postwar Germany and Japan would surpass that of America’s, and to maintain its imperialist streak, the empire chose to end the Bretton Woods arrangement and hyperleaped into finance capitalism, but that’s a story for another day.

The important point here is that China has to launch a Marshall Plan if they are serious about challenging US dominance. There is no point selling cheap Chinese EVs to African countries in exchange for their raw materials, for that will not help those countries industrialize and will only perpetuate their status as colonies to yet another superpower.

What China needs to do is to first, use its massive dollar reserves to pay back Africa’s and the Global South’s debt, then give those countries yuan - the Chinese currency - in order to support purchase of Chinese goods. This will in turn raise the income of the Chinese working class, increase their purchasing power, and will enable the Chinese workers to import goods and services from the Global South countries, raising their income too and fund the development of those countries.

Most important of all, this will also lower the massive trade surplus in China (yes, China will lose its net exporter status, but does China really want to compete with other poorer economies to manufacture low value added goods like shoes and clothings?), paving the way towards a bancor-like mechanism to return the world economy to a more balanced trade, and towards ending US monetary imperialism once and for all.

But there is no indication at all that China is willing to do this. The dollar hegemony has greatly benefited the Chinese economy over the past 30 years, and so we end up in this comical situation instead, where Trump is actively trying to end this mutually beneficial arrangement while China runs with “protectionism bad! free trade good!” defense.

But sooner or later, everyone will have to accept that neoliberalism has run its course. But, will it be the US new fascist technofeudalism that takes its place, or a socialist model upheld by the Global South?