Anyone who stumbles upon that title out of context will probably say "Oh look, the commies support pedophiles. What a shock." and they're free to think that, as wrong as it is. So let me break it down.
In the last few years, To Catch A Predator has had a huge resurrgence in popularity because pedophiles are awful. The one group in America that everyone can agree are bad, now that we're okay with actual Nazis apparently. When you watch a lot of TCAP, a thought thoughts to burrow it's way into your mind "If I were there, this sicko would get what's coming", so naturally a bunch of amatuers decided to start making their own little predator stings. These usually don't work because YouTubers are more concerned about making content than protecting kids. The police aren't involved, a lot of the videos are actually cases of entrapment that aren't actionable in court, and my personal favorite, many of these YouTubers just beat the shit out the suspected predator for a while. On camera.
First off, I think a lot of those are fake because the liklihood that you can attack already mentally unwell people and not be shot or stabbed is pretty low. But secondly, these videos are a degenerative disease. No one is getting helped, no one's being stopped because these cases are thrown out, and things are beginning to escalate. I mentioned that a lot of catchers are physically attacking their marks. One instance where this happened a man was shot and killed because he pretended to be a teenage girl and then punched a 16 year old in the face, who shot him in self defense. Things are also getting out of hand in other ways. Recently a group of college kids abducted a guy because he wanted to date an 18 year old, which is both not illegal and not grounds to kidnap someone for clout.
The most dangerous thing about these people is the feedback loop they've created on social media. Child Molesters are bad, this is an established fact that everyone agrees on. Police aren't doing enough (this is partially true but it's a poor justification). So if you take issue with the idea of guys getting their asses kicked by vigilantes on camera, or that they "accidentally" get the wrong guy, then you're a pedo sympathiser and someone should go kick your teeth in too. A group of people with no accountability or oversight can just decide your guilt and act on it. Why are we creating a world where someone can call you this or that and then send violent thugs after you?
This isn't just about pedophiles either, what I'm getting at is that the definition of the "acceptable target" will only expand until more and more people are caught in the crossfire. That kidnapping I mentioned? That's just the beginning, because that is the logical conclusion of this behavior.
I can't speak to all of the catchers, but I stress that 99 percent of pedophile catches aren't based in violence or beating up the predator, even if they deserve it sometimes.
I'm extremely suspicious of people who claim "entrapment!" because catching someone doing a crime isn't entrapment.
Legally speaking, only law enforcement can entrap someone. And it's only entrapment when you are coerced into doing something you wouldn't normally do. Claiming "entrapment!" isn't a magic get out of jail free card, and it doesn't make it entrapment.
I have never ever in almost a decade of watching predator catching videos, almost never seen even a single instance where catchers attacked a pedophile, unless the pedophile runs or attacks first, and not even then.
Alex Rosen is on my shitlist. He himself has admitted to being a pedophile, and then covered his ass by claiming it's a joke.
Despite catching multiple hundreds and hundreds of scumbags, and the vast, vast majority of them being much closer to stereotypical rednecks, he still believes in this "LGBT groomer" conspiracy, and he is a reich-wing agitator and a disgrace to actual hunters.
I have no problem with someone making a living from donations for catching pedophiles, as long as they don't spout racist and sexist and transmisogynistic conspiracy theories, and they don't lick cop boots too much.
You gotta do what you gotta do to buy groceries, in a capitalist society.
Edit: Jesus Fucking Christ, that better be bots or neoliberals downvoting me. I'm disappointed and pissed off that people have a problem with justice.