I had a discussion yesterday with someone who thought that Israel had no choice so i argued that if that was the case then the rightists wouldnt have assassinated Yitzhak Rabbin, they wouldn't have feared that the peace process succeed, that solutions are available but we're not discussing them, etc. etc. And then in the evening my twitter feed led me to this link which i felt worth including here.
It's hard not to think that left vs. right is simply good/nice/ empathetic/.. vs. bad/selfish/"realist"/..
Also, it's annoying but we're still hearing, even almost 2 years later, that if Hamas released all hostages then the "war" would end immediatly, that is such bullshist, so easily debunkable, so here are some examples illustrating that we're being 'lied to'/ manipulated :
- 18th October, 2023 : Hamas Ready To Release All Hostages If Israel Stops Bombing Gaza ;
- November 2023 : What's blocking has never been the released of the hostages, even at the beginning, if you remember the ~first peace talks :
«Talks between Israel and Hamas have been stymied by disagreement over whether a ceasefire should include an end to the war. Hamas says a ceasefire must include the end of the war and a full withdrawal of Israel’s military from the Gaza Strip, which Israel has refused.
Israel says it will only end its war in exchange for the dismantling and exile of Hamas, which Hamas has refused.
An offer had already been on the table. Hamas had reportedly offered to release all hostages in exchange for a full withdrawal of Israel’s military from Gaza and an end to the war. On Sunday, Hamas official Mahmoud Mardawi reportedly said
Netanyahu insisted on a temporary agreement that releases only 10 hostages.
Mardawi accused Netanyahu of setting “impossible conditions aimed at thwarting the possibility of reaching a ceasefire agreement and a deal on the hostages.” »
It lead to an end of the truce in december 2023. - 21st January 2024 : Once again, Hamas continues to offer to free all hostages, in exchange for palestinian hostages/"prisoners" and the end of the unilateral slaughter/"war", and, again : «"In exchange for the release of our hostages, Hamas demands the end of the war, the withdrawal of our forces from Gaza, the release of all the murderers and rapists," Netanyahu said in a statement. "And leaving Hamas intact." "I reject outright the terms of surrender of the monsters of Hamas," Netanyahu said.» ;
- 7th February 2024 : Hamas 'freedom fighters'/"terrorists" don't trust Israel to keep their words so ask for a progressive release, while Israel says it'll continue until every last terrorist is dead : https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/gaza-mediators-search-final-formula-israel-hamas-ceasefire-2024-02-07
- 7th May 2024 : the peace plan is still a progressive exchange of hostages, an end of the war, but now also include humanitarian aid and an end of the blocus, while Israel stays on its position that it won't end until every terrorist is dead, and begins the Rafah offensive ;
(Etc., there's no point in being exhaustive) - 17th April 2025 : Just one more unneeded proof that Israel could have reached an agreement to recover their hostages(, instantly this time and not progressively,) but chose instead to recover them by force : https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/hamas-is-ready-release-all-remaining-hostages-return-an-end-gaza-war-hamas-gaza-2025-04-17. One does not negotiate with terrorists, or something.
So let's not hear again and again that this war would be over tomorrow if Hamas released the hostages, because that's a very obvious lie stemming from (y)our ignorance.
(Even if killing thousands of people to liberate hostages was the only way, you don't do that obviously, but that's not even the only way since they only asked for an end of the war in exchange)
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/11/27/palestine-and-israel-brief-history-maps-and-charts